Note: this column is part of a point counterpoint debate regarding the new policy to ban smoking on campus. Click here to read the other half.

On March 29, the Student Government Association (SGA) held a meeting to address student concerns about the proposed campus wide smoking ban. Those who attended discovered that  there was no actual, concrete reason given for the ban.

Out-going SGA student body president, Alex Henry, speculated about reasons for the ban. He cited concern for some students and staff who are allergic to cigarette smoke, the mess created by cigarette butts being littered on the ground, and the failure of security guards to enforce the smoking restrictions currently in place.

The SGA then heard arguments, both for and against the ban. They recorded the statements of 30 plus students against the ban, and three who were in favor of it, and said that they were going to present them before the CGC executive team that will be voting on the ban.

A CGC representative at the meeting, who would not give her name, said that there was not an executive team in place but that the CGC was going to hold a meeting to elect one. The elected team would then go on to vote on making the campus smoke free. She wouldn’t say when the meeting to elect the executive team was going to be held, and wouldn’t say who first proposed the ban.

Perhaps the most offensive reason offered is that no one should be able to smoke because some students and staff are allergic to the smoke. This is a transparent attempt to eliminate smoking while appearing benevolent and caring. If there was any actual concern for student health, Mercer would have a full-time nurse and they would have replaced the lone psychologist, who quit last month. The cafeteria and vending machines should stop selling products that contain nuts, and start serving low-fat, hypo-allergenic choices.

If they are really worried about the mess, they could put more ashtrays at the designated smoking areas and acknowledge the efforts of students like third year Theater Arts major Nick Andrejco who organized a cleanup team to sweep up all the stray butts laying around campus. Andrejco and his team did this in less than an hour on the day of the SGA meeting.

Maybe the real problem is CGC is mad that security isn’t enforcing the current policy, but making a more extreme policy is guaranteed to fail spectacularly. It would be like banning cars because cops weren’t writing speeding tickets. That thinking makes no sense. It’s bad enough that Mercer has a totally unenforceable visible ID tag policy, but adding another completely unenforceable policy? How can anyone take this school seriously when the people in charge believe it is reasonable to burden 15 security officers with the obligation to police an estimated four thousand smokers (presumably in between checking the ID’s of 12,000 students)? It’s wrong headed and embarrassing.

Frankly, Mercer has pursued a number of foolhardy notions of late, from letting a felonious professor stick around to rile up his classes through the end of the semester, to putting in $160,000 flashing signs at the school’s entrances. It’s time for a win for Mercer, and banning smoking on campus will not be it.

 

Print Friendly
Share this:
Facebook Twitter Pinterest Tumbler Email

Tags: , , , , , , , , , ,

Ken Napier
advert

One comment on “New smoking ban shows Mercer’s penchant for unenforceable policies

  1. Pingback: New smoking ban: right spirit, wrong strategy | The VOICE

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

50,076 Spam Comments Blocked so far by Spam Free Wordpress

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

CAMPUS CRIME REPORTS: Mercer files annual reports revealing low crime, doesn’t fix years of incorrect filings

By: Kevin Xavier and Carl Fedorko The rape and murder of a Lehigh University sophomore, Jeanne Clery, drew national attention […]

Mental health care difficult for Mercer students to access due to stigma and lack of availability

  In a typical week, Dorothy Gasparro sits down with twelve to fifteen Mercer students to help them work through […]

Judges rule text senders could be liable in civil court

Three New Jersey State Appeals Court judges: Judges Ashrafi, Espinosa and Guadagno, announced on August 27, 2013 that text senders, […]

MCCC faculty contract ratified by Board of Trustees, ends bitter dispute

For the last seven months Mercer’s faculty union and the college’s administrators have been locked in a heated negotiation over […]

MCCC fashion program is steadily growing under Allegra Ceci’s guidance

Asia Mack, a second year fashion design student at Mercer, wasn’t sure what to major in when she finally picked […]

MCCC nursing student Sarah Poinsett beats cancer

Sarah Poinsett was 26 years old, working full time in a daycare, raising her six-year-old, Kayla, on her own, and […]

Rock band No Reason records “Every Path Has a Purpose”, goes on tour

Up and coming local rock band No Reason has been playing in the area lately. Founded in January 2011 as […]

C&C Cafe in Trenton features great Caribbean food

A mixture of Caribbean and soul food can be found at C&C Cafe which is located on the bottom level […]

MCCC baseball team gears up for run at region XIX championship

For three consecutive seasons Mercer has reached the Region XIX Championship tournament, only to be defeated by Lackawanna College, derailing […]

MCCC men’s basketball overcomes eligibility problems to rally for playoffs

In early January the Mercer Men’s Basketball team was floundering. Their roster was down to six players to begin the […]

Chris Christie shifts stance on DREAM act

The DREAM Act, a bill which allows access to in-state tuition benefits at public universities for undocumented college students, was […]

Higher education saddles college students with intolerable student debt

I was arguing with the God of the Mercer Bookstore, who took a female form that day, about why I […]

Caribbean Restaurant Hot on D Spot feels like Trinidad in Trenton

The second you step inside the door of Hot on D Spot Roti Shop you’re transported from Hamilton, New Jersey […]

Mercer County Community College Baseball team has 5 players recognized nationally

After falling short of the region 19 championship last season, the Mercer Baseball team is returning a lot of talent […]

Video game design systematically marginalizing women

The video game industry has a problem with gender representation. But if the media ever hopes to reach its full […]

This site is protected by Comment SPAM Wiper.
Social links powered by Ecreative Internet Marketing